This post was written by Karl Whelan
NAMA Chairman Frank Daly gave an interesting speech today. NAMAWinelake analyses the speech in detail here.
Daly discusses how NAMA may get sales going in both the commercial and residential property markets. In terms of commercial property, Daly describes how NAMA can provide finance in a simple and clear manner which hopefully will dispell some of the confusion about this issue when it first came up (the point of this post was that it was a very simple issue but that didn?t stop us getting various comments about where would they get the money from, the whole thing being circular and Ponzi schemes and the like ?):
To illustrate how stapled financing might work in practice, let us take the case of an investor who wishes to buy a property asset from a NAMA debtor or receiver but who cannot source any funding or sufficient funding from banks even though he is willing to contribute 30% equity. Assuming a purchase price of ?100m, the investor would pay ?30m upfront to NAMA and then enter into a loan agreement for the residual ?70m which would see him repaying the principal on an amortising basis to NAMA over a five/seven year horizon. The original debtor?s outstanding obligations to NAMA would fall by ?100m. The net impact for NAMA would be positive in a number of respects. It would have generated a transaction in the market which would not otherwise have taken place. It would have replaced a loan of ?100m with what is likely to have been a weaker debtor with a performing loan of ?70m with a stronger debtor, thereby reducing and diversifying its credit risk. It would also have a cash receipt of ?30m which it could then use to reduce its own debt. In reality, it does not require any new money from NAMA; it is a recycling of existing debt but achieving a significant cash payment upfront.
The comments about selling residential properties are more interesting. Because the maturity of most residential mortgages extends well beyond NAMA?s projected lifespan, they are keen to get involved with the two pillar banks to provide mortgage finance. Interestingly, NAMA appear to be willing to provide funds to insure purchasers against future price declines:
Our aim would be to unveil a product with the two banks in the early autumn which meets a number of key criteria: one which generates sales of property controlled either by NAMA debtors or by receivers yet provides an incentive to purchasers to invest at current prices in the knowledge that there will be a mechanism in place which will offer them protection against the risk of negative equity in the event that prices should continue to fall. Given that NAMA is effectively providing state funds for this purpose and the pillar banks will be largely state owned, it raises a question about whether such mortgages should be offered beyond the limited set of residential properties owned by NAMA.
Finally, this passage will prove popular with many:
A number of debtors appear to be trapped in the old mindset whereby it is they and not the lender who sets the terms on which business is done. It is akin to falling overboard and then complaining to your rescuer about the colour of the lifebuoy that he is about to throw in your direction. Some of them have difficulty surrendering the grandiose lifestyles that they seem to regard as their continued entitlement, even if the rest of us are expected to pay for it through higher taxes and cuts to services in our schools and hospitals. We have and will enforce against such debtors. If the taxpayer is being asked to keep you in business, it would seem to be a matter of basic common sense that you do not seek to maintain a lifestyle that is beyond your means. The taxpayer does not owe you a living and certainly does not owe you an unrealistic lifestyle if you are not in a position to repay your debts.
Tough words. Let?s see if they?re accompanied by corresponding actions.
Tags: Mortgages, NAMA
Source: http://www.irisheconomy.ie/index.php/2011/05/19/frank-daly-on-nama-providing-finance/
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.